5 Mistakes Fintech Marketers Make with Content Marketing (And How to Avoid Them)

August 11, 2025 •  min read

By Araminta Robertson

Managing Director

 In the past few years at Mint, we’ve helped over 20 fintech companies with their content.

We’ve helped one fintech grow customer acquisition by 700%. We’ve helped one bring in customers worth thousands of dollars. We’ve helped another get over 30 leads per month with content, and with another one, content was a more cost effective lead generation channel than paid website ads.

With all that experience and those results, we’ve seen what works and what doesn’t, and we’ve noticed a pattern of mistakes fintech marketers make when creating content.

Note: do you work for a fintech company and want to create content that brings in leads? Set up a discovery call with us and we’ll help you find out if content might help you with lead generation.

❌ Mistake 1: Not tracking leads and conversions

Many marketers and content marketers track the success of their blog content based on traffic numbers. As long as traffic is increasing month over month, then their content is succeeding.  

Although traffic is an important metric, it won’t give you the full picture. Simply because: an increase in traffic does not always equal an increase in leads and conversions

At the end of the day, the lifeline of a business is revenue. And if you’re a CMO or marketing manager, then you know that at the end of the day your leadership team wants to know the impact of your efforts on revenue. 

As we’ve explained in other articles, we’ve been able to get deals for clients worth over $60k with traffic at just 200 to 300 sessions per month (specifically to our blogs). If we had only focused on traffic, then our content efforts would have been deemed a failure. 

But because we were tracking the metrics that mattered – leads and conversions – via Hubspot, we could see how many leads we were bringing in as well as the value of that lead. We could demonstrate the contribution of our content and the value, which shows that our content is actually succeeding.

(this is what our Hubspot dashboard looks like)

As a marketer, make sure you’re tracking the leads and conversions that your content is bringing in. If you can prove you’re bringing in leads, then it’ll be easier to make a case to the leadership team that the company should keep investing in content.

❌ Mistake 2: Starting with Top of the Funnel content

Top of the Funnel (TOFU) content is what you might call educational content, or thought leadership. It’s content that targets people who don’t even know they have a problem yet. It’s often for brand awareness and positioning.

TOFU content is important, but if you are currently getting pressured by the leadership team to bring in results, then does it really make sense to target people who could take over a year to convert? 

We believe it makes more sense to start with Bottom of the Funnel (BOFU) content. That means writing content targeting people who know they have a problem, know what the solution is and are actively looking for it online. 

That way, you can get more conversions and leads and get the low hanging fruit: people who are ready to convert. If you’re not targeting these people, then you are essentially leaving customers, and therefore revenue, on the table.

We always think it makes sense to do BOFU content first: this will get you results early on, and that will make it easier to get buy-in from the leadership team. 

Ideally, you want to take advantage of SEO and target BOFU keyphrases that indicate that your target market is actively looking for a solution like yours. Those might be keywords like “top payment provider” and “fintech payment solution”.

By starting with BOFU, we were able to bring in leads for a client within month two of working with them. Read the case study here: How We Generated Leads for This B2B Fintech Client in Month 2 (In a Competitive Landscape!).

Join our newsletter

Get updates every time we publish content!

    ❌ Mistake 3: Creating content based on desk research

    We’re not saying desk research is bad. We’re saying that if you have Subject Matter Experts on your team (and many fintech companies do), then why not base your content on their expertise rather than online research? 

    Many freelance writers and agencies will create thought leadership or blog content based on desk research of Google, eBooks and white papers. But your reader doesn’t want to read the same thing written in a different way: they want to read something new and useful.

    Instead of creating content based on desk research, we believe it’s better to base your content on interviews with experts. There are a few benefits to doing it this way:

    1. If one of your missions is financial education, then creating expert-based content will ensure what you’re sharing is genuinely useful and adds to the discussion. 
    2. If your goal is to position yourself as an expert in the market, then expert-based content will help you stand out since it’s literally coming from experts.
    3. By creating content based on expertise, you can add in details about your product, market and customer that you might not be able to do otherwise. This helps build trust in the eyes of your target market, and is more likely to turn them into a customer.

    For example, in this article on PayTo (a new type of payment method in Australia), we’re able to go in-depth about certain use cases and examples. We’d never be able to do that solely with desk research: 

    ❌ Mistake 4: Not writing for the level of your reader

    You may have seen this type of content before:

    If you’re a CFO or product manager and you read this, do you think you’d be impressed or want to work with that company?

    We’ve seen a lot of fintech companies think that SEO content means writing content that’s for beginners. But what’s the point in writing for someone who isn’t in your target market (unless they eventually will be)? Why write about the details of what a payment method is, when your target market is looking for information on APIs?

    Based on our experience, we find it makes a lot more sense to write for the level of your buyer. They are the ones who will become your customers. By educating them and giving them the right information, they are also more likely to be interested and reach out. By writing for beginners, you risk alienating your real target market and targeting the wrong people. 

    And by creating content based on an interview with an expert, this is a lot easier. Product managers, CTOs and technical people want to see:

    • Diagrams
    • Screenshots
    • Examples and use cases
    • Details

    By writing this advanced type of content, we’ve had salespeople at our clients’ organisations say that “they are lucky to have this type of content”. If you’re embarrassed by your content, then it’s not a good sign. Instead, you should aim to be proud of the expertise you’re able to share with readers.

    ❌ Mistake 5: Not focusing on revenue and customers

    Finally, this is the most common mistake we see in the content marketing industry.

    As we mentioned at the beginning, many people in content marketing will focus on traffic, and other metrics like backlinks, domain authority and number of keywords.

    And sure, sometimes these metrics are relevant. But you should never lose sight of the main objective with marketing, which is ultimately revenue. 

    The focusing on the wrong metrics leads to many content marketers and agencies basing their content strategy on “keyword research”. This often involves putting a competitor’s website through an SEO tool, picking a few keywords and then voila: those are your content ideas.

    Again, this might work if you’re just trying to bring in traffic. But the ultimate goal of a company is to bring in revenue via customers – so why focus on traffic when you can bring in customers?

    Instead of targeting the same keywords that your competitor is targeting, target the prospects who are searching for your solution. Instead of basing your content strategy on what everyone else is doing, base it on what your customers are searching for online. What indicates that they have a pain point? That they’re looking for a solution? That they’re not happy with their current solution?

    Every content strategy we do is based on lengthy discussions with a salesperson, a growth person, founders and product people. We ask them specific questions to understand what a customer is looking for, and create a strategy based on that. 

    With this approach, we’ve been able to create content that competitors haven’t even thought of, and most importantly, we’ve been able to create content that helps our clients grow their company by acquiring more customers.

    We hope with this article in mind, you’ll be able to avoid the same mistakes we’ve seen other marketers do in fintech. 

    Want to learn more and read more about content with fintech? Check out these resources:

    Curious to see if our content methodology would work for your company? Book a call with us and we’ll help you determine if content would help your fintech company.

    Find out if content marketing would work for your company  

    Share this post

    https://www.mintcopywritingstudios.com/blog/fintech-content-marketing-mistakes

    Tags

    No items found.
    Blog

    What’s new in content and financial services

    Newsletter: Does increased LLM visibility lead to more customers? Here's what we found via 3 case studies
    January 23, 2026

    Newsletter: Does increased LLM visibility lead to more customers? Here's what we found via 3 case studies

    This post breaks down Mint’s “GPT articles” framework for boosting LLM visibility and shows, with real client data, that it doesn’t just increase brand mentions in tools like ChatGPT — it drives high-quality leads and real sales opportunities. The takeaway: targeting the right BOFU prompts through LLM-optimised content is now a powerful new customer acquisition channel, especially for early-stage companies.

    Newsletter: Is your content actually working? Four questions to find out
    January 16, 2026

    Newsletter: Is your content actually working? Four questions to find out

    To prove content is really driving revenue, look beyond traffic and track four signals: rankings for buying-intent keywords, lead volume and quality, and whether your content is cited by LLMs like ChatGPT. Together, these show whether your content is influencing real buying decisions and pipeline, not just awareness.

    Newsletter: How this fintech almost 3x'd organic inbound leads with content
    December 20, 2025

    Newsletter: How this fintech almost 3x'd organic inbound leads with content

    This case study shows how Yapily, a niche B2B open-banking fintech, nearly tripled (2.8x) its organic inbound leads by focusing on bottom-of-the-funnel “money keywords,” optimising existing content, and implementing robust lead attribution. It proves that even highly specialised fintechs can drive high-quality, measurable growth through strategic SEO and content.

    Does increased LLM visibility lead to more customers? Here's what we found via 3 case studies
    December 18, 2025

    Does increased LLM visibility lead to more customers? Here's what we found via 3 case studies

    Based on GPT articles and our experiments, read how about how an increase in LLM visibility leads to an increase in inbound customers.

    Newsletter: How can marketers use AI effectively to create better content?
    December 5, 2025

    Newsletter: How can marketers use AI effectively to create better content?

    While AI can speed up content creation, over-reliance risks producing generic, inaccurate, or shallow material, especially in regulated sectors like fintech. He recommends using AI strategically, such as through custom GPTs, SEO integration, and formatting support, to enhance content without compromising accuracy or brand trust.

    Newsletter: Clicks are decreasing, should we be worried?
    November 24, 2025

    Newsletter: Clicks are decreasing, should we be worried?

    Organic clicks are falling across the board thanks to AI Overviews, but it’s not a crisis. It’s a signal that traffic is no longer the KPI that matters. The brands winning now are the ones shifting their focus to conversions, attribution, and real revenue impact.

    Newsletter: Want content that people trust? Interview your experts
    November 7, 2025

    Newsletter: Want content that people trust? Interview your experts

    In a world drowning in generic AI content, the edge comes from real voices. That’s why Mint creates content powered by expert interviews — the kind that adds depth, builds credibility, and actually converts.

    Case Study: How Content Helped Yapily Achieve 2.8x Growth in Organic Inbound Website Leads
    November 7, 2025

    Case Study: How Content Helped Yapily Achieve 2.8x Growth in Organic Inbound Website Leads

    Learn how we helped Yapily achieve a 2.8x increase in organic inbound leads and rank for 94% of key buying keywords — and how a bottom-of-funnel, expert-led content strategy made it happen.

    How Fintechs Do Content: Volt and the Power of Truthtelling Content
    October 28, 2025

    How Fintechs Do Content: Volt and the Power of Truthtelling Content

    Volt is reshaping fintech marketing by trading hype for honesty. Under ex-journalist Charlie Gilbert’s lead, the brand champions clear, story-led, and “selfless” content that informs rather than sells—building trust, brand recall, and credibility in the crowded world of open banking.